Skip to content

Downton Abbey vs. Upstairs Downstairs – the claws are out!

Posted by 31 January 2012 19:44

Downton Abbey vs. Upstairs Downstairs – the claws are out!

Eek! There’s always been a bit of underlying rivalry between ITV’s Downton Abbey and BBC’s Upstairs Downstairs, but things are getting competitive in the run-up to their return later his year. After its successful Christmas episodes in 2010, the BBC drama is back on our screens this spring and will be set around the First World War. Sound familiar?

Upstairs Downstairs writer Heidi Thomas has defended the similarities with Downton though, saying, “Downton have had 18 hours of drama now and we are barely out of the starting blocks. I think this is a whole new chapter for us. We just don’t reference Downton and I have only seen fragments of it myself.” She said to The Daily Mail, “If you are going to pick up the story, you don’t have a choice about covering the war.”

Downton is "sexless"

This comes after Upstairs Downstairs actor Neil Jackson, who plays raunchy chauffer Harry Spargo, blasted Downton for being a “sexless show” in The Sun earlier this month. He even went on to slate the Crawley ladies, saying, "The women in Downton Abbey don't compare to the women in Upstairs Downstairs. Ours are stunning. We've got beautiful women.” Miow!

Neil then went on to argue that Upstairs Downstairs is more sexed-up than Downton, saying, “I have several steamy sexy scenes… And there are entire storylines I'm not involved in that will have audiences' mouths agape from just the shock and audacity of the sexual nature.” Did he not see the episode where Mary had a one-night stand and Mr Pamuk died?! It was scandalous!

We’re not sure we like all this arguing. It’s like if Ryan Reynolds and Ryan Gosling started fighting… We love you both, don’t make us choose! If it does come down to fisticuffs, we’re imagining Neil Jackson and Dan Stevens (Matthew Crawley) in a camp slap-fest a la Colin Firth and Hugh Grant in Brigitte Jones, though. In fact, if any TV bosses are reading this, that’s a great idea for a show.

Which show’s return are you most looking forward to? Is Neil fair to say Downton is sexless? Forget the ladies though, we want to know which show you think has the best-looking men! Let us know…

Average rating: 3 stars (4 votes)

Where to go next

4 Comments

  • thekatiegee

    01 February 2012 09:22

    Yeah downton is set in 1918, girls wern't sexy then, if they had the slightest bit of leg showing they would probably have been disowned. It's still the best show on telly at the moment! I'd rather watch downton re-runs than towie or xfactor

    thekatiegee

  • StunnedBanana

    31 January 2012 23:11

    Downton is the best! It doesn't need to have raunchy sex scenes to be interesting.

    StunnedBanana

  • Sara00

    31 January 2012 21:54

    Never seen Upstairs Downstairs. Isn't it from the 70's? Or was it back on? This article has left me confused!

    Sara00

  • jillymac

    31 January 2012 21:03

    Well I'm looking forward to Downton. Was so excited for Upstairs Downstairs but was left disappointed by it. Expected more from the BBC. Downton all the way!!

    jillymac

Explore Heatworld

  • Celeb News

    All the hottest celebrity gossip, news and pictures from the around the world

  • Style

    Fashion, beauty and other things that look pretty

  • Entertainment

    All the latest movies, music and TV news and reviews

  • Club Heat

    Videos, pictures, games and other things to make you giggle

  • X Factor

    All the latest gossip from the hit show - X Factor!

  • Big Brother

    All the latest UK Big Brother and Celebrity Big Brother news