Oooh, this is a tough one. As much as we adore Leona Lewis (and we really do, bless her), we're not convinced that tights were really necessary with this gorgeous Jenny Packman frock. High School Musical star Ashley Tisdale (who we also love, being the newly-converted HSM fans that we are), wore her version with strappy sandals and bare legs to a premiere in Australia earlier this month, while Leona sparkled in hers at the American Music Awards and accessorised with some chunky bangles. The dress is fab and both ladies look gorge, but who do YOU think deserves the winner's crown? Vote away and let us know.
Who wore it best?